Tribunal Judge Raps Taxpayer for Using AI to Cite Non-Existent Tax Cases

A taxpayer has been reprimanded by a tribunal judge after using AI to support his appeal with fictitious tax cases.

Marc Gunnarsson, who represented himself, was asked to provide supporting arguments in the Upper Tribunal after HMRC rejected two claims for the Self-Employment Income Support Scheme (SEISS) totaling £12,918 during the pandemic. However, he made a critical error by relying on an AI chatbot to substantiate his case.

The Upper Tribunal chastised Gunnarsson for including fictitious cases in his skeleton argument, which was submitted just one day before the hearing. Judge Rupert Jones highlighted that the skeleton cited three supposed First-tier Tribunal (FTT) decisions: Patel v HMRC [2023], Ali v HMRC [2022], and Kamran v HMRC [2023], which allegedly supported Gunnarsson’s interpretation of SEISS legislation. One of these references claimed reliance on advice from an accountant, while the other two addressed SEISS guidance and eligibility.

“These cases do not exist and are classic AI hallucinations,” Judge Jones noted. He emphasised the dangers of relying on AI for legal arguments without verification:

“The accuracy of artificial intelligence (AI) should not be relied upon without checking, particularly regarding statements or arguments about the law. Unrepresented parties, like legal professionals, are responsible for the accuracy, reliability, and credibility of the information and submissions they present to the FTT or UT. In this case, HMRC had to investigate the purported decisions, which could have gone undiscovered under different circumstances.”

While this was not the first instance of AI generating false cases in tax tribunals, Gunnarsson was given some leeway because he is not legally trained. Judge Jones described him as “not highly culpable” but warned that in other cases, the misuse of AI could lead to serious consequences. Sanctions for such misuse are outlined in the Ayinde case and can be applied by the Upper Tribunal.

Upper Tribunal Ruling on SEISS Claims

Initially, the First-tier Tribunal had allowed Gunnarsson’s claim, but HMRC successfully appealed to the Upper Tribunal. The original assessment concerned two SEISS payments totaling £12,918 received by Gunnarsson during the 2020 pandemic: one on 26 May 2020 and another on 16 September 2020. HMRC concluded that he was not entitled to either payment, as he was not a “qualifying person” under paragraph 3.2 of the Schedule to the First SEISS Direction and was not self-employed at the time.

At the time of his claims, Gunnarsson was the sole director and shareholder of Machinegun Web Development Limited (MWDL), incorporated on 5 July 2018 and dissolved on 27 July 2021. Before 2018, he had worked as a freelance web developer, which fell outside the SEISS eligibility period. His 2019-20 self-assessment tax return showed dividends of £19,336 and employment income of £7,230, totaling £26,566, but no self-employment income.

Gunnarsson argued he had sought advice from his accountant regarding SEISS eligibility. However, HMRC’s guidance, updated on 13 May 2020, clarified that SEISS was available only to self-employed individuals.

The Upper Tribunal ruled against Gunnarsson, stating that the FTT erred in granting the SEISS payments. Judge Jones noted:

“To the reasonable and ordinary taxpayer, it would be apparent that the guidance implied that a person employed by or a director of a limited company would be ineligible for SEISS in respect of services provided by the company. The FTT erred by failing to apply the law correctly or at all, relying instead on non-binding guidance rather than the legislation.”

The tribunal referenced the SEISS decision in Joshua Taylor as providing the correct legal analysis. The Upper Tribunal remade the decision, dismissed Gunnarsson’s appeal, and allowed HMRC to recover the funds through income tax.